The advantages of a traditional boiler system (E61) mentioned in the video include superior temperature stability for consistent espresso quality and better steam quality for milk texturing. Disadvantages include slower heat-up time and higher energy consumption compared to thermoblock systems.
The speaker prefers traditional boiler systems because of the superior quality of the espresso produced and the more robust build quality and materials used in their construction. He feels that the longer heat-up times and higher energy consumption are acceptable trade-offs for the better espresso and overall feel of the machine.
This video compares thermoblock espresso machines ("Dickfilmheizer") to traditional boiler systems. Davide Costanza discusses the technical differences between the two systems, their advantages and disadvantages, and ultimately helps viewers decide which type of machine best suits their needs.
Thermoblock/Dickfilmheizer Systems: These systems heat water quickly via a heating element surrounding a thin water channel. They are faster to heat up and are more energy-efficient but can suffer from temperature instability and produce lower-quality steam. They are also more prone to limescale buildup.
Traditional Boiler Systems (E61): These utilize a larger boiler that maintains a consistent water temperature, resulting in more stable espresso temperature and better steam quality. They are slower to heat up and consume more energy, but provide a more consistent and higher quality espresso.
Comparison: The video highlights the trade-offs between speed and energy efficiency (thermoblock) versus temperature stability and steam quality (boiler). The choice depends on individual priorities (e.g., speed of brewing vs. espresso quality).
Material & Build Quality: The speaker emphasizes the difference in build quality and materials between the two system types. Boiler systems tend to use more robust and durable materials, resulting in a perceived higher quality.
Personal Preference: The speaker shares his personal preference for boiler systems due to the superior espresso quality and overall build quality despite longer heat-up times and higher energy consumption.