Gaggiuino vs. Gaggimate: And The Real Winner Is...

About this video

• Video Title: Gaggiuino vs. Gaggimate: And The Real Winner Is...
• Channel: Espresso Hackers
• Speakers: Not specified in the transcript.
• Duration: 00:23:40

Overview

This video compares the Gaggiuino and Gaggimate systems for espresso machines, analyzing their features, performance, installation, and cost. The speaker aims to help viewers decide which system might be a better fit for their needs, acknowledging that the "real winner" depends on individual priorities and risk tolerance.

Key takeaways

• Temperature Stability: While Gaggimate uses a PID algorithm and Gaggiuino has a more complex system, the speaker found no major difference in temperature stability between the two in preliminary tests.
• Pressure & Flow Profiling: Gaggimate's pro version now includes pressure and flow profiling, similar to Gaggiuino. However, Gaggiuino offers more advanced control, allowing combined flow and pressure targets in the same phase, which Gaggimate currently lacks but may implement in the future.
• Scales and Automation: Gaggiuino has integrated hardware scales allowing for "stop on weight" functionality. Gaggimate does not have this, requiring an external Bluetooth scale, which adds cost and can reduce clearance.
• Interface and Software: Gaggimate has a 2.4-inch touchscreen, while Gaggiuino Gen 3 has a larger 4.3-inch screen. Both offer headless interface options. Gaggiuino's software is more mature due to its longer development time, while Gaggimate is rapidly evolving with frequent updates.
• Cost and Delivery: Gaggimate is slightly cheaper than Gaggiuino (€261 vs €227 for the pro versions). Gaggimate also offers significantly faster delivery (1-2 weeks vs 2-3 months for Gaggiuino).
• Open vs. Closed Source: Gaggimate's code is open source (with attribution required), while Gaggiuino Gen 3 has closed its code to prevent unauthorized resellers.
• Installation: Gaggimate appears to be more beginner-friendly with better documentation and video tutorials, and also offers optional 3D printed parts for convenience.
• Conclusion: Functionality-wise, Gaggimate is nearly on par with Gaggiuino Gen 3. The speaker leans towards Gaggimate due to faster delivery, potentially easier installation, and a cheaper option for users not needing advanced profiling. However, this choice depends on individual risk aversion, as Gaggiuino has a more established track record.