This video presents a virtual reality simulation designed for educational purposes, focusing on historical events during the Roman Republic's transition. It guides users through historical scenarios, requiring them to make critical decisions and understand the political and social dynamics of the time, particularly concerning Octavian's rise to power. The simulation also includes a tutorial on VR controls and a mechanism for users to collaborate with a partner outside the VR headset.
Here are the notes and decisions based on the VR simulation:
Would YOU support or oppose Octavian being granted even greater powers? I would lean towards opposing Octavian being granted even greater powers, at least initially.
Why? My primary concern is the preservation of the Republic's principles and institutions, even if imperfectly realized. The arguments for Octavian focus heavily on stability and order, which are crucial, but the arguments against him highlight the dangers of unchecked power and the erosion of representative governance. The historical precedent of figures like Cicero and the brutal methods used (displaying tongues and hands) are deeply concerning. While stability is necessary, it should not come at the cost of foundational principles that prevent tyranny. It feels like a dangerous path to grant absolute power, even with good intentions, as it can easily be corrupted. The fear of becoming a tyrant is a more significant risk than the potential benefits of absolute order.
Would YOU support or oppose Octavian being granted even greater powers? After gathering all the information and seeing the consequence of opposing Octavian (arrest, likely execution), I would reluctantly support Octavian being granted greater powers.
Why? The simulation starkly illustrates the practical consequences of opposing a consolidating power. While the arguments for the Republic's ideals are noble, the reality presented is that dissent leads to severe repercussions, as seen with the senator accused of peculatus. The overwhelming majority of senators supporting Octavian, coupled with the clear message that opposition is dangerous and futile, forces a pragmatic choice. Siding with Octavian, despite the compromises to republican ideals, appears to be the only way to ensure survival and potentially influence from within, rather than immediate destruction. The argument that the Republic is already a sham also weighs heavily, suggesting that clinging to a dying ideal might be less beneficial than adapting to the new reality and trying to shape it.
Yes, absolutely! The simulation is designed to be an educational tool, so framing the takeaways and decisions in a more "student-like" manner is fitting. Here's a revised version, focusing on a student's perspective and learning process:
Part 1: Initial Exploration & Arguments
Why Support Octavian? (What the simulation told me):
Why Oppose Octavian? (What the simulation told me):
Before Switching Roles: My First Decision
Would I (as a student learning this) support or oppose Octavian getting more power right now? I'd probably oppose him at this point.
Why? Even though Octavian seems to be bringing peace, it feels like he's doing it by crushing everyone else. The stories about Cicero and the violence are really disturbing. I think it's more important to try and keep the Republic's ideas alive, even if it's messy, than to let one person have all the power and risk turning into a dictator. It's like choosing between a scary but potentially fairer system and a safe but possibly unfair one. I'd rather take the chance on fairness.
Part 2: After Switching Roles & Final Thoughts
More Reasons to Support Octavian (What I learned from my partner/new info):
More Reasons to Oppose Octavian (What I learned from my partner/new info):
My Final Decision (Looking at everything): Would I support or oppose Octavian getting even more power? Okay, after seeing how Octavian got rid of the guy who opposed him and how everyone else voted for him, I'd have to support him.
Why? It's like in class – sometimes you have to make a tough choice based on what's actually happening, not just what you wish was happening. The simulation showed me that opposing Octavian means you probably get arrested or worse. Since most senators voted for him, and clinging to the old Republic seems impossible now, it feels safer and more practical to try and work within his new system. Maybe I can still influence things from the inside, or at least keep my family safe, which is what the supplier character was worried about. It's disappointing, but it feels like the only smart move left.
How This Game Helps Us Understand Today (Connections):
