How PROFESSIONAL Software Engineers Code vs Vibe Coding

About this Video

• Video Title: How PROFESSIONAL Software Engineers Code vs Vibe Coding
• Channel: Eric Roby
• Speakers: Eric Roby
• Duration: 00:06:44

Introduction

This video compares how professional software engineers utilize AI coding tools (like Cursor AI) versus "vibe coding," a term referencing complete reliance on LLMs for coding without reviewing code or errors. The speaker, Eric Roby, a software engineer with over 10 years of experience, explains his approach to using AI in his workflow.

Key Takeaways

• Professional AI Coding: Eric uses AI tools like Cursor AI, GPT, Claude, or Gemini strategically. He uses detailed prompts for initial project structures and then reviews and refines the AI-generated code, addressing potential issues with framework versions or technology updates. He emphasizes iterative, small requests to maintain control and prevent blindly accepting potentially flawed code.
• Vibe Coding Critiqued: Vibe coding, defined as complete reliance on LLMs without code review, is presented as potentially risky. The speaker cautions against this approach, emphasizing the importance of understanding and validating AI-generated code.
• Pros of AI-Assisted Coding: Faster initial project setup, quicker coding, and assistance with overcoming coding blocks are cited as advantages. However, this is contingent upon pre-existing coding skills and understanding.
• Cons of AI-Assisted Coding: Potential decline in critical thinking and design skills due to decreased manual coding effort. Also, over-reliance by junior developers can lead to maintainability and scalability problems in their projects.
• Recommendation: Use AI tools strategically, learning from them but not completely depending on them for all aspects of software development. Maintain a strong foundational understanding of coding principles.