This Triggernometry video features Richard Miniter discussing the historical roots of American political and cultural divisions. Miniter argues that understanding America requires acknowledging its founding as four distinct, somewhat coercive religious utopias originating from different periods in British history. He traces these origins back to the English Civil War, showing how the resulting cultural influences continue to shape contemporary American politics.
Four Founding Utopias: America was founded by four distinct groups with different origins in Britain (Puritans from East Anglia, Royalists from Southwest England, West Midlands settlers, and Scottish borderland settlers), each bringing unique cultural and religious values that continue to influence American politics.
English Civil War's Legacy: The English Civil War (Roundheads vs. Cavaliers) significantly impacted American culture. These opposing ideologies—Puritan legalism and Royalist hierarchy—persist in modern political divisions.
Cultural Impact on Modern Politics: Miniter analyzes how these historical cultural divisions affect contemporary politics, explaining the appeal of figures like Donald Trump by their alignment with specific cultural groups and their rejection of hyper-liberal progressivism.
The Shifting Balance of Power: The relative influence of these four cultural groups shifts over time. Currently, the South (Cavalier tradition) is gaining influence, while New England (Puritan tradition) is declining. The “rust belt” is shifting right, while the Appalachian region remains relatively static.
Resurgence of Traditional Religion: The video notes a recent resurgence in traditional religious practices across the U.S., particularly Catholicism, partially attributed to the social isolation and uncertainty amplified by the COVID-19 pandemic. This religious shift has political implications, influencing voters' self-reliance and views on the role of the state.
