This Triggernometry video features Richard Miniter discussing the historical roots of American political and cultural divisions. Miniter argues that understanding the English Civil War and the distinct cultural groups that settled America is crucial to understanding present-day political conflicts. He analyzes four distinct utopian settlements and their lasting impact on American society.
Four Utopian Settlements: America was founded by four distinct groups from different regions of Britain, each with unique religious and political beliefs: Puritans (East Anglia), Cavaliers (Southwest England), Middle States settlers (West Midlands), and Appalachian settlers (borderlands near Scotland). These differing origins created inherent cultural conflicts that persist today.
Cultural Impact on Politics: These historical divisions significantly influence modern American politics. Presidential candidates typically gain support by appealing to their core cultural base and winning over one or two additional groups. Trump's success is attributed to his appeal to those favoring individual liberty (proto-libertarian impulse) and hierarchical social structures (Cavalier).
Shifting Power Dynamics: The relative influence of these four cultural groups has shifted throughout American history. Currently, the Cavalier South (represented by states like Texas and Florida) is experiencing a surge in power due to internal migration, while the Puritan Northeast's influence has waned.
Resurgence of Traditional Religion: A resurgence of traditional religious views, particularly Catholicism, is noted. This is partly attributed to the COVID-19 pandemic, prompting a search for certainty and community amidst uncertainty, but also to broader societal factors like social isolation and a yearning for traditional values, particularly among younger men.
Accountability vs. Unaccountability: A significant conflict exists between the "accountable class" (those whose income is tied to results) and the "unaccountable class" (those whose positions are secure regardless of performance). The unaccountable class, often associated with left-leaning policies, is seen as resistant to reform and accountability, which is fueling resentment among the accountable class.
