When a cheap espresso machine beats an expensive machine (for dark roasts)

About this video

• Video Title: When a cheap espresso machine beats an expensive machine (for dark roasts)
• Channel: The Sunny Square
• Speakers: None explicitly named, but a single narrator.
• Duration: 00:07:19

Overview

This video compares a basic, inexpensive espresso machine with a high-end prosumer machine (Escasso Steel Duo) to determine which produces better espresso, particularly for dark roasts. The analysis covers build quality, heat-up time, performance with different roast levels, and overall value.

Key takeaways

• Cost vs. Quality: A $100 espresso machine can, surprisingly, produce a better-tasting dark roast espresso than a $2,000 machine due to its lower brew temperature and pressurized portafilter.
• Machine Differences: The cheap machine is primarily plastic with basic internals, a fast 28-second heat-up time, and a non-standard portafilter. The Escasso Steel Duo is a robust, metal machine with precise temperature control, pre-infusion, and dual heating elements, designed for a more involved espresso experience.
• Roast Performance:
  • Light Roasts: The expensive Escasso Steel Duo excels with light roasts, offering precise temperature control to bring out bright, fruity notes.
  • Dark Roasts: The cheap machine performs better with dark roasts, as its gentler extraction and pressurized portafilter prevent over-extraction and bitterness, resulting in a smoother flavor.
• User Preference: While the Escasso is the overall winner for espresso enthusiasts who appreciate nuanced flavors and control, the cheap machine offers a surprisingly satisfying experience for dark roast lovers seeking simplicity and good taste.
• Gear is Relative: The video suggests that while high-end gear has its advantages, it's not always the determining factor in espresso quality, and sometimes simpler machines can outperform complex ones for specific coffee types.