About this video

• Video Title: Which iOS DAW Sounds Best? // GarageBand VS Logic Pro for iPad VS Cubasis 3 VS BandLab
• Channel: The GarageBand Guide
• Speakers: None specified
• Duration: 00:12:28

Overview

This video compares the built-in software instruments of four leading iOS Digital Audio Workstations (DAWs): GarageBand, Logic Pro for iPad, Cubasis 3, and BandLab. The creator imports MIDI arrangements of popular songs into each DAW to evaluate how their instruments recreate the original tracks, focusing on sound quality without any mixing or tweaking.

Key takeaways

• Instrument Sound Comparison: The primary goal is to determine which iOS DAW's instruments sound best when recreating existing songs.
• Methodology: MIDI arrangements of songs were imported into GarageBand, Logic Pro for iPad, Cubasis 3, and BandLab. No mixing or tweaking was performed.
• GarageBand's Brass Issue: GarageBand has a notably poor "Brass Ensemble" instrument that makes compositions using it "unlistenable," requiring a replacement with a basic French horn sound in some cases.
• Logic Pro's Guitar Weakness: Both GarageBand and Logic Pro for iPad are noted for having subpar software instrument guitar sounds that are described as "cheap and crap."
• BandLab's Strength: BandLab is highlighted as a "dark horse," with its woodwind and other wind instrument sounds being particularly praised. The creator found BandLab to be a favorite overall for its instrument quality.
• Cubasis 3 Balance: Cubasis 3 is described as sounding balanced and clear from the outset, with particularly nice flute and oboe sounds, though its drums are noted as a bit "flat."
• Song Examples: The video features comparisons using Queen and David Bowie's "Under Pressure," Michael Jackson's "Smooth Criminal," and Toto's "Africa."