Why Good DMs Screw Up "Twists" in D&D

About this Video

• Video Title: Why Good DMs Screw Up "Twists" in D&D
• Channel: Bob World Builder
• Speakers: Bob
• Duration: 00:14:52

Introduction

This video discusses how Dungeon Masters (DMs) can effectively incorporate twists into Dungeons & Dragons (D&D) campaigns. The video focuses on three key aspects: hinting at the twist beforehand, ensuring the twist gives the players something rather than taking something away, and carefully timing the twist within the game session. The speaker uses examples from movies, TV shows, and his own experiences to illustrate these points.

Key Takeaways

• Hints are Crucial: A successful twist requires foreshadowing or hints to allow players to piece it together upon the reveal, enhancing player satisfaction. The absence of hints leads to a jarring, unsatisfying experience.
• Giving, Not Taking: Effective twists should add to the player experience, not detract from it. Instead of removing something the players have worked for (like destroying their newly acquired ship), a good twist provides new challenges or opportunities (e.g., capturing a powerful enemy).
• Timing is Everything: Unlike in movies where end-of-story twists are common, D&D twists are more impactful when placed earlier in a session. Ending a session with a twist can be jarring due to player fatigue and the disruption of their sense of accomplishment. A cliffhanger is suggested instead.
• Discovery-Based Gameplay: The video advocates for discovery-based gameplay, where the DM plans less and allows player choices and creativity to shape the game's direction, making it easier to incorporate engaging twists.
• Reluctant Recollection: A successful twist allows the players to recall previous hints and clues, giving the reveal a satisfying "aha!" moment.